A collection of essays, outdoor adventure stories, ruminations, wordplay, parental angst, and blatant omphaloskepsis, generated in all seasons and for many reasons at 64.8 degrees north latitude

Wednesday, July 9, 2014

Just Passing Through




Photo of our community living room, blatantly stolen from Scott Pauker's blog
(http://spokeandwords.com/hitching-prudhoe-bay-part-2/)
When the kids and I found the sheet of fresh cookies and the pan of homemade brownies that Scott Pauker had left on our kitchen counter, I felt a twinge of regret that he would not be there to share them with us. 
Not that our little community of nine adults and four kids would have any trouble gobbling down the treats without outside assistance.  We have a strong track-record in Postprandial Gooey Deliciousness Consumption.  It’s part of the rhythm of the evening, which starts when we hungrily gather to sniff out whatever the chef du jour has concocted, and ends when we drag unwilling children home for necessary slumber. 
Dinner itself is usually gratifyingly replete with dark leafy greens, organic legumes, and whole-graininess.  While dining – and in the comfortable after-supper half-hour of plate-scrubbing and leftover-wrapping – we all decompress from work, gripe about current events, share our very best in off-color humor, or (in the case of the eight-to-ten-year-old crowd) happily absorb the off-color humor while bouncing off the walls.  Finally, we settle down to the pleasures of Dessert Time.
For two evenings during the previous week as well as two evenings this week, Scott had made a nice addition to that tableau.  His sunburned grin radiated his total lack of concern at finding himself in the midst of some kind of weird intellectual hippie mini-commune.  They use an outhouse and make jokes about Oxford commas?  Yeah, I’m cool with that.  He filled us in on enticing tidbits of Seattle news and biking lore.  He shared amusing details of his Adventure Thus Far -- and we were fond of his penchant for washing more than his share of the dishes. 
But, of course, he couldn’t hang around Fairbanks, Alaska forever.  He had places to go…such as Tierra del Fuego.  On his bicycle.
“Will we ever see him again?” asked Molly. She was indirectly responsible for the hoard of baked stickiness that was now brightening our morning with the joys of anticipation; with the honed cunning on an almost-third-grader, she’d been the fastest responder when Scott had kindly asked what sort of foodstuffs he might contribute to the general well-being of Tamarack Knoll. 
“Probably not,” I admitted.  “But we can follow his adventures online, if you want.”
“Okay.”
Molly sounded interested rather than disappointed.  She’d liked Scott.  Still, at age eight, she already seems well-acquainted with the fact that people come and go.  Travelers don’t always return. 
She strapped her own bike helmet over her raincoat hood for the decidedly less epic ride to this week’s summer camp – Shakespearean acting for the eight-to-twelve set – and the subject shifted to the question of why Lizzy’s bike has a rear mud-guard, while her twin’s does not.  But, as we splashed our way up our dirt road, and as I offered pointers on what gear a bike ought to be in on a steep incline (“Try a lower one, kiddo… no, a LOWER one…”) I found myself mulling over how we relate to the transient people in our lives: The Travelers.
I’ve blogged previously about the importance of community; of friendships; of sense of place; of ties that are permanent (okay, fine, not permanent on an intergalactic scale, but you know what I mean); and of people who are SO AWESOME that one can pawn off one’s kids on them at short notice. These myriad bonds are at once as complex as calculus and as comfortable as couch cushions.  In our clock-watching, parking-lot-infested, glowing-screen-riddled lives, the time-and-connectedness algorithms are often tricky to compute, and the fabric of community needs a bit of darning, to say the least.  But where, in weaving that mathematical tapestry, do we place the person who is new, foreign, strange, unknown, and temporary?  What is the role of The Archetypal Traveler?
The Traveler shows up in plenty of stories, from the Odyssey on out.  He or she is the Gypsy, the Tinker, the Explorer, the Warrior, the Vagabond, and the Stranger all rolled into one.  She is the Fairy Godmother, who appears for just long enough to do her trick with the pumpkin.  He is that Brad Pitt character who runs off with all the money in Thelma and Louise – but that’s not why you remember the character, now is it?  He is Gandalf, who never quite seems able to stick around long enough for the entire adventure, due to mysteriously pressing business elsewhere. 
Scott, of course, is not an archetype; he’s a specific, cheerful, 37-year-old man from Seattle with muddy Spandex and a liberal-arts background.  But, for the purposes of my ruminations, he makes a splendid archetypal proxy. We’d never heard of him until a few weeks ago.  He came our way as the friend-of-friends-of-friends, in a Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon kind of way. 
Jay mentioned to me, in a vague sort of way, that “some biker guy” might be passing through, like, sometime, and did I think the community would be okay with letting him crash in the guest room?  As the Communications Specialist of the family (a job that falls to me by default, not based on any useful skillset), I posed this question to whomever happened to be around, received some unperturbed “yes” responses, and promptly forgot all about it until my phone rang, showing an unknown out-of-state number. 
“You’re where?  Old Nenana?  Okey-doke, you should be here in about twenty minutes.” 

I went to find a set of sheets, some sandwich-fixings, and a towel with not too many holes in it.
The Traveler is, by definition, is on the move. He’s not merely someone you’ve never met before; he’s someone who has been places you’ve never been, and is going places you probably can’t even imagine: “You’ve never heard of the Millennium Falcon? … It’s the ship that made the Kessel run in less than 12 parsecs.”
Han Solo may not have known the difference between units of distance and units of time, but he was definitely going places: "Look, I ain't in this for your revolution, and I'm not in it for you, princess. I expect to be well paid. I'm in it for the money.” The traveler may or may not be one of the Good Guys in White Hats, but he’s interesting – and undeniably, oddly magnetic.
The Traveler doesn’t just crop up in literature (yes, of course Star Wars is literature!); he or she also seems to crop up with some regularity in our community.  Why?  Well, I’m not sure.  It might be because, given that there are five households in our group, we naturally receive five times the standard-issue number of guests.  It might be because Fairbanks is the kind of place where people frequently couch-surf – sometimes in a not-getting-off-this-couch-without-a-crowbar kind of way.  Or it might be because our community has an excellent reputation for not yet having slaughtered a single visitor in our ten-year history. 
Be that as it may, the vast majority of our guests have brightened and enlivened our lives.  Fairbanks is not a place that people “just pass through” unless they are up to something just a bit peculiar – such as a stint at Toolik Lake field station, measuring arctic shrubbery while enjoying the enthralling company of a few billion mosquitoes. We’ve housed researchers, families, relatives, and strangers.  We played host to the now-community-legend Fred, a retired African-American factory worker who came up to Alaska just to take part in the White Mountains 100 wilderness race.  I’d explain all about Fred, but this sign that the kids made says it all.  

Some of this enlivenment-via-house-guest, granted, involved a sort of after-the-fact “Type 2” fun.  The young woman who left a large, bloody, meaty item in our freezer, for example… well, she might have been lacking a few rudimentary social skills, but she left us with a most excellent story.*
Why are we drawn to The Traveler?  Why, knowing that we have no chance of developing a permanent bond, a reciprocal relationship, or even a real friendship, do we eagerly take in the traveler, make him a sandwich, and tell him to “make himself at home”?  Scott gave us wine, dishwashing, and brownies, but such generosity wasn’t expected or required.  What intangibles make The Traveler worthwhile?
What is The Traveler giving away for free?  Well, in the course of my 42 years, I have not only encountered The Traveler many times; I’ve also been The Traveler.  When I signed up to join the US Peace Corps at the ripe old age of 21, I had only the vaguest notion of what it might mean to go away and live in a less-developed foreign country for two years.  That is, I thought about many of the things I might have to give up: running water, electricity, spaghetti, Cadbury’s.  I didn’t understand quite so clearly what it might mean to give up familiarity, belonging, being at home.  I didn’t understand what it would be like to have to explain – weekly, daily, hourly – everything about myself, my worldview, my race, my nationality, my culture.
But there was no choice.  I was The Traveler.  I needed to describe snow to children who had never experienced temperatures below sixty Fahrenheit.  I needed to describe the American educational system to people who had struggled to get as far as seventh grade.  I, a lone white woman in a sea of resentment, needed to discuss racial tensions, the misunderstood plots of soap operas I’d never seen, the entire history of slavery, what New York City is like, the fact that I was NOT a Mormon missionary, class warfare, hurricanes, the CIA, school gardens, international trade, and English grammar.  My role as story-teller was non-negotiable.
I recall, with peculiar clarity, the day when I was seating at the bottom of a pit – destined to be a new school latrine -- with a shovel and crowbar.  The temperature was well over ninety.  It always was.  I was dripping.  But I was digging with fierce determination, in part because I knew that everyone had one eye on their own work, and one eye on me.  As I worked, a very old man, seated comfortably above-ground, turned to no one in particular and wheezed, with absolute conviction, that white girls sure can dig an outhouse.
If it hadn’t been clear before, it was clear then: the payment for my acceptance was not only my tales from afar, but also my role as a proxy for every American that everyone had never met.  I was The Traveler.   And being The Traveler is fascinating.  It’s exhilarating.  It’s also utterly exhausting – although not usually in the bone-weary sledge-hammer sense.  It’s draining socially, psychically, and emotionally. 
Scott passed through our humble not-a-commune on his way north to the official start of his bike ride at the Arctic Ocean.  He passed through again on his way south.  We saw him for a total of four evenings.  Since then, we’ve followed some of his adventures via Facebook and his blog.  “Oh, look, Scott made it to Whitehorse… Hey, did you read the piece Scott wrote about Skinny Dick’s Half-Way Inn?…” 
We won’t see him again.  The brownies are long gone.  The kids are not pining for the missing guest.  But when another Traveler gets in touch with us (by text or Facebook or pure-white carrier pigeon tossed upward from the slopes of a mythical volcano), we’ll welcome her.  We’ll make her a sandwich, and offer her a shower (replete with caveats about our limited water supply).  And we’ll ply her for stories, for mystery, for vicarious armchair-adventure.  She’ll understand the currency.  It’s one with a long history, and yet – despite the Age of Communication, despite supersonic speeds and instant messaging and a distinct lack of tinkers, magicians, Gypsies, and bundle-carrying train-hopping hobos in  a world grown small -- it still clings to shreds of its former value.
Community spells comfort, familiarity, home.  Without a community of friends and family, it’s easy to feel lost, ungrounded, purposeless.  The Traveler, on the other hand, symbolizes the mysterious, the unknown, the adventure you haven’t yet had, and the places you haven’t yet seen – but might.  Without The Traveler, the world can seem too small, too dull, too unchanging, too lacking in possibility. Thus, Community and Traveler are yin and yang.  We need one because we need the other.  And– at least at some time in our lives – we all need to take at least a brief turn at carrying the tales.  We probably won’t cover as many parsecs as Han Solo.  We probably won’t keep our pedals turning all the way from the Arctic Ocean to the tip of South America.  But we’ll at least gain some appreciation for those who do.
Happy trails, Scott.


* The young woman in question called us up about six months later and told us that she’d be swinging by to pick it up.  When we informed her that’s we’d thrown it away (not without some confusion and disgust), she was incensed.  “You threw away my bear heart?!”

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

The One Secret Trick...



Based on the ads that clutter the edges of my computer screen, I should be worried about a lot of things.  These include my wardrobe (“The latest in plus-size fashion!”), my finances (“Interest Rates Plummet!”), and my shoes (“Dozens of cute styles!”).  But there is one problem that the Internet Gods feel is even more appalling than my lack of trendy new pumps: the hideous signs of my decrepitude.

I should be stressing out about the dry skin on my feet, the wrinkles on my face, my maternal abdominal fat, and my general overall sagginess.  Scars are a biggie, too.  I should be trying to smooth them.  Erase them.  Photo-shop them.  Something.  Anything!  Indeed, I should be in a state of continual semi-panic about the visible effects of the Sands of Time. 

My proximal reaction is amusement at how poorly the digital universe seems to be tracking me. I’m not terribly prone to tinfoil-helmet-type fears; my thoughts are not valuable enough for anyone to want to steal them.  Still, it makes me snort and giggle to see just how wide of the mark these ads fly.   I’m pretty sure it doesn’t take an MBA to guess that a person who spends her time reading peer-reviewed journal articles, cracking obscure Star Trek jokes, and utilizing an online text-to-hexadecimal translator is probably not in the market for “The Revolutionary Secret That Dermatologists Hate!!!”

Come on, Google and Facebook, can’t you do any better than that? With all my keystrokes at your disposal, you still don’t know me one whit!

Or… do they? 

Oh, I don’t mean that I’m about to get liposuction and dermal abrasion, or start sighing abjectly in front of a mirror. (I can hear my friends snickering.)   Nonetheless, I do sometimes feel a disorienting disconnect with my sense of self.  Is that forty-two-year-old mom really… me? 

I clearly remember the summer day when I had recently reached the exalted age of ten, and my mother divulged that, deep down, she was still a ten-year-old, too.  The idea that my reliable, stolid mom-parent was simultaneously the pigtailed child grinning impishly from black-and-white post-WWII-Britain both comforted and terrified me.  Part of me wanted to cling to the childish idea that she – and all grownups – were omnipotent, omniscient beings who existed in a higher plane than my own.  But at the same time, I was already feeling the complex world of adulthood closing in on me like a pall of dense smoke.   I already knew that I didn’t ever want to lose my essential self. When it came time to navigate that daunting world, I wanted to still be me.  The me I knew. 

I am now the age that my mother was, on that particular day in 1982.

I don’t obsess over vanishing beauty; I never had it to lose, anyhow. At ten, I was not an adorable Shirley Temple; I was a grubby little nail-bitten creature often found somewhere high up in a tree.  At fourteen, I was not a peachy, blossoming young sylph; I was an uncomfortable collection of bony elbows, scraped knees, and miserable uncertainty.  At nineteen, I was not a gorgeously unblemished young lady with perfect curves; I was a doughy lump of acne skulking in a shapeless pair of overalls.  But through those horrifically awkward and sometimes terrifying years, I still believed that I could grow up to do world-changing things.  Cure cancer?  Visit Mars?  End war?  Discover new subatomic particles?  Heck, yes.  I adored logic puzzles, science fiction, running around in the woods, and asking way too many questions.  I liked inventing, and building.  I liked playing.  Playing!

And then Father Time wreaked a quarter-century of collateral damage. 

Facebook wants me to worry about the physical wear-and-tear and the visibly droopy bits, but what about the metaphorical scars and blemishes?  The wrinkling and graying of my perspective and personality?  The cumulative scarring of all of life’s failures and disappointments and disillusionments? Those seem far more difficult to treat with ointment, loofahs, supportive undergarments, or That One Secret Trick Your Doctor Won’t Tell You*. 

A few months back, a friend in his late thirties who is half-heartedly doggy-paddling around the dating pool expressed consternation about the fact that all the women he met had “emotional baggage.” 

My middle-aged cynicism kicked in instantly.  Baggage?  What, just like mine?  Just like yours?

Jay, who has been married to me for a full dozen years now, was about as unsympathetic as I was in the face of our friend’s complaint.  His thoughts on the matter, however, were radically different from mine.   While I inwardly harrumphed that all of us middle-aged farts carry a gray, wrinkly knapsack of past woes, Jay stoutly (and sweetly) maintained, “That’s silly.  Not all women have baggage.  Nancy doesn’t have any baggage at all.”  Yes.  He actually said that out loud.

Oh, Heavens to Betsy.  The assertion alone threw all the dirty laundry in my head into a fast spin cycle, churning up the staple set of humiliating and miserable memories that refuse to fade into obscurity.  I’m sure that hundreds of happy days have blurred together into a polyglot, but the most sparkling examples of my personal idiocy, embarrassment, and loss are as immovable and as obtrusive as pillars of polished marble. 

I should pause here to say that, given that I don’t have Baggage-with-a-capital-B, I have absolutely no ability (and no right whatsoever) to comment upon the agony of extraordinary emotional pain, loss, or paralysis, any more than I have the ability to imagine what it might be like to suffer physical paralysis. Nor do the Facebook ads that plague my screen offer cures for debilitating diseases, severe burns, or past abuse. They focus on the superficial effects of the passage of years: the everyday wear-and-tear and the inevitable scars, not the profound ones.  The ones we all acquire.  With time.

I worry that the impacts of all those small scars have cumulatively, yielded a crop of cynicism, inertia, and stolidness.  I peer in the metaphorical mirror, suspecting myself of giving up adventure for security and reneging on idealism and perfectionism in favor of Just Getting Shit Done.  Do I see just a hint of jadedness around my eyes?  Is my optimism sagging, thus allowing my sarcasm to flop around?  How did I get to be forty-two years old without ever paragliding, publishing a novel, or setting foot in Africa?  Why can’t I watch romantic movies without groaning and rolling my eyes, rather than sighing and tearing up?   At what point did the wrinkles of time inform me that my vote in the next Presidential election probably won’t matter, the Indigo Girls aren’t all that profound, and I’m never going to go to Mars?  My idealism is mottled with stretch-marks, dammit!

Stretch marks.  Yeah.  Okay, fine.  What about them?  The real, physical ones, that is.  Maybe there’s something I can learn from the physical that will inform the metaphysical.  So, okay, what of all the other physical changes and scars? 

I took stock of my scars.  And I found a few stories.

Left knee: don’t slide into first base if you are a second grader playing whiffle-ball in a parking lot. 

Right thigh: don’t go hiking up snowfields with an ice axe that you don’t know how to use. 

Left thigh: if invited by a family of Jamaican farmers to stop by any time before five o’clock, do not arrive five minutes late, after they have set loose their pack of trained German Shepherd guard dogs.  But if you do, pretending you came to play super-fun doggie games will fool five-and-a-half of the six. 

Lower abdomen: removing twelve pounds of tightly wedged twin by C-sections, by Jay’s report, involves a crowbar. 

Left breast: some lumps are benign.  Some days are full of gratitude. 

Arms: if you donate blood enough times – like maybe fifteen gallons or so by now – you’ll eventually have a collection of little needle-marks.  But they’re not junkie-marks, okay?  Okay? 

Face: for gods’ sake, stop picking at the acne!  Also, dusk in moose territory is a bad time to be driving relatively fast on a gravel road – but the doctor and two nurses in Meadow Lake Saskatchewan in the summer of ’99 were a kind, down-to-earth, and deeply generous team with a copious supply of heavy-duty black thread.

What does this all add up to, other than a complex roadmap of scar tissue (private tours -- by invitation only)?  Well, first of all, it shows that modern medicine is nothing to take for granted.  Second, it’s clear that I’ve gotten off pretty darned easily.  Third, it shows that scars tell a complicated story of good and bad luck, good and bad choices, and lessons fairly or unfairly learned.  But I think it offers a few broader hints, as well. 

One of those hints is – I kind of like my scars.  Mythologically speaking, those who try to turn back time do about as well as those who try to stop the tide or fly with wax wings.  But I don’t want to stop time, and more than I want to erase my scars.  My worries have less to do with my neck-veins, my unsightly calluses, and my too-too-solid thighs than with world-traveling still undone, world-saving still unaccomplished, and relative lack of parties at which everyone blasts the music immoderately high and starts taking clothes off – and these desires, I now realize, don’t have to be tied to anyone’s calendar but my own.

Yeah, I’m female, and yeah, I’m middle-aged.  As a result, the Advertising Gods think they have me pegged: “You Won’t Believe Our Miracle Scar-Erasing Crème!”

No, you’re right, I won’t believe. 

But there are things I do believe – and one of them is that I’ll happily ignore you, Facebook Advertiser.  I don’t want your snake-oil goo.  I don’t want your Dorian Gray outlook on life. I don’t want to erase my scars, expunge my past, return to high school, or reclaim all the fears, credulity, insecurities I’ve shed along the way. 

On the other hand, there are things I do want to hang onto.  My optimism is one of them. I want to believe that I can make a difference, that some songs are worth getting stuck in my head, and that sure, I will still travel the world one day with just a backpack on my back.  I want to stay up too late, and run around in the woods, and ask too many questions.  I want to eat s’mores with that once-me ten-year-old.

I’m pretty sure she’s here with me for good.  She’s a bit battered and scarred.  But… that’s okay.  She’s in for the long haul.




*Admittedly, my doctor does seem awfully youthful, but I’m pretty sure she’s not holding out on us.

Sunday, May 4, 2014

As Yoda as you wanna be








You are Spock.  Logical and sharp-witted, you are a natural for the role of Science Officer…

Oh, heck, yes.  Science Officer!  Logical!  Sharp-witted!  Of course I am.  I’m totally Spock… unless I take the online quiz again, choosing a different favorite shirt color.  In that case, I am... the starship captain?

You are Kirk. With a quick mind and a way with words, your decision-making abilities and persuasive personality are legendary. A worthy warrior and a convincing orator, you are just as likely to talk an adversary to death as to engage in physical combat.  Prone to long-winded bouts of rhetoric, you are nonetheless known to be a charmer.

What?  Long-winded bouts of rhetoric?  Um… like, say, seventy-one blog posts, all jam-packed with words, and all hewing closely to the well-honed topic of Whatever Nancy Happens to be Thinking About?

Oh.  Yeah, okay.  I guess I’m… a little Kirk-y… except for the charming part.  I’m pretty sure I’m severely lacking in that department, because I never, ever find curvaceous green women in my bed.*  But, regardless of my ways with the ladies – or lack thereof -- I definitely think of myself as more Spock-y.

But in the world of online quizzes, do my preferences really matte?  Once the results appear on the screen, the quiz has spoken -- and it has me pegged. (You are Yoda.)  It knows me. (You are Aragorn.)  It has completely figured out who I am. (You are Katniss.) It is providing me with a flattering mirror, a personal affirmation, a somewhat vague yet mostly complimentary box in which to put myself.  You are Spock.  That’s who I thought I was, and that’s who I am.  I’m validated.  Isn’t that why we take these quizzes in the first place?

A recent New Yorker article (Maria Konnikova, May 1 2014) posited as much, citing the well-known “Forer Effect” as a reason why these tests appeal to us, and why we believe what they tell us.

In 1948, psychologist Bertram Forer told his students that the typewritten sheets he was handing out were unique analyses of the personality of each member of the class, based on the questionnaire they’d filled out previously.

In reality, every “analysis” was exactly the same.

“You have a great need for other people to like and admire you... You have a great deal of unused capacity which you have not turned to your advantage… Disciplined and self-controlled outside, you tend to be worrisome and insecure inside… You pride yourself as an independent thinker and do not accept others' statements without satisfactory proof….”

The students, when asked to rate these results, were almost universally impressed by their accuracy.  Yes, that’s totally me!  I’m Spock, for sure!

So much for “independent thinker”.  So much for “satisfactory proof”.

The term “Forer Effect” was henceforth used to denote the now many-times-tested principle that people will overwhelmingly buy into the accuracy of vague personal assessments, provided that these assessments include lots of positive statements and are believed to be personally tailored to the individual.

Fortune-tellers and horoscope-writers wallow lucratively in the Forer effect – and did so long before it had a name.  Bolstered by the not-so-subtle cues of body language, dress, mannerisms, age, and gender, there’s a heck of a lot that Madame Zelda can tell you about tall dark strangers, personal aspirations, or the curvaceous green women you’re longing to find in your bed.

But are these online quizzes just a whole load of crystal-ball mumbo-jumbo?  What makes it SO DAMN TEMPTING to know whether I am a kick-ass teen-girl Defender of the Right named Katniss, or her sensitive, artistic, bread-baking boyfriend Peeta?  Why do I care whether an online algorithm says I’m Leia or Yoda, or (as promised by one peculiarly obscure quiz) Basil, Oregano, Marjoram, or Tarragon?  Why do I want to click?  IT’S NOT LOGICAL!

…Like Spock, you struggle with ethical dilemmas that seem at odds with your innate sense of reason…

Precisely.  It’s not logical.  In fact, the addictiveness of these quizzes is so illogical that they bring out all my most evil and sarcastic urges.  You’re going to tell me, in a Facebook post time-stamped at 1 a.m., that your “herbal archetype” is Basil, which indicates that “…you have a beautiful soul, and it shines through in the way you treat others?”  Alas, I am clearly not Basil myself, unless perhaps I’m Basil Fawlty.  My un-beautiful soul sniggers, and starts crafting new archetypes:

"You are bacon salt. Tacky and artificial, you tend to raise the blood pressure of anyone with whom you interact...."

"You are jeotgal. Like a long-fermented fish, your company is memorable -- but not at all in the way you'd like to be memorable..."

"You are chervil. Everyone sort of vaguely thinks they've heard of you, but no one knows what the hell to do with you, so they'll probably just go right on ignoring you..."

Of course, none of the “real” results are likely to tell you that you are an insufferable loser with all the personality and side-effects of a bucket of MSG. Can we possibly learn anything from these ultra-brief tests if all the results are benign and complimentary?  Does anyone take these quizzes and discover that they are Darth Vader, Cersei Lannister, and Cruella DeVille rolled into one tidy Hitler-flavored package?  Probably not, unless they are a thirteen-year-old hell-bent on rigging the results.

Still, I find myself wondering whether the quiz-player might (just might) be discovering something a little beyond what can be gained from a newspaper horoscope.  After all, even if the set of results is limited, this is not quite the same as Forer’s “something for everyone” uniform output.  In answering one of these questionnaires, and in agonizing over choice A or choice B, I am examining some of the traits that make a person the hero, the sidekick, the comic relief, or the villain.  I am, at least at some level, searching my psyche.

Am I Tyrion Lannister?  Please?  Really. I mean, I know that being a bitter, tragic, violent, whoring, drunken dwarf doesn’t sound all that great on paper, but I really want to be that bitingly funny, that stereotype-busting-tough, that sharply brilliant, that… Tyrion.  I want to know and affirm myself, yes, but I also want to mold myself, change myself, and reimagine myself.

The urge to discover ones archetype via the internet in the wee hours is not entirely logical, but I’m not convinced it’s merely the Forer Effect at work.  To me, accepting Forer’s results stems from our (very human and almost universal) tendencies to want to fit in, to feel that we are known and understood, to see ourselves in a relatively positive light, and to be obliviously self-centered.  Konnikova cites this rationale in the New Yorker, and I do agree that part of the appeal of “Which Star Trek Character Are You?” lies well within this realm.  However, the Forer Effect doesn’t really reflect intense curiosity, a trait that is also very human and almost universal -- but a lot more fun than complacent self-appreciation.  Nor does it reflect self-doubt, or the urge to live closer to a large yet untapped potential – two qualities so ubiquitous that they were happily accepted as individually true by almost every student in Forer’s psychology class.

Am I Tyrion Lannister?  And if not, how can I become him?  How can I find the right answers – and the right self – to be blaster-toting Empire-defying Princess Leia rather than pedantic, cowardly, pointy-headed, irritating (albeit weirdly loveable) C-3PO?   And if I’m not Basil, how can I be… more Basil?

…but you recognize the value of these internal struggles in growing as a person…

Exactly.  Sure, it might be more effective to try to examine and remake ourselves via years of psychotherapy, several 12-step programs, a Master’s Degree in engineering, a new exercise regimen, and a public-speaking course.  It might be logical to realize that eight or ten questions pertaining to your attitude on Away Missions, your response to warp-drive failures, and your preferred color of uniform shirt probably can’t help you find an inner self that is a dramatically more scientific or radically more likely to woo the aliens.  But most of us don’t have the time, money, or fortitude for the Full Archetypal Makeover.  We struggle along with the limited TV-referenced role-models we have at hand. That doesn’t mean that we aren’t trying.  It doesn’t mean that we aren’t hoping.  And it doesn’t mean that we can’t change.

The New Yorker article notes that people blatantly lie on online quizzes.  Well, maybe.  I mean, come on, I REALLY want to be Tyrion!  But if you are lying (to yourself) about (your own) emotional states and (your own) preferences, maybe it’s not so much dishonesty as, I don’t know, questing?  The psychological literature tells us – over and over again, on behalf of our kids and ourselves – that we become whom we imagine or believe ourselves to be.  Tell a child she’s stupid, irresponsible, and mean, and you might well end up with exactly the kid you prophesied.  Tell yourself you are brilliant, narcissistic, and psychopathically cruel, and you too can be Cersei. But learn to believe – really believe -- that you are brave in the face of tyranny, deeply wise (with enough humor to offset your gravitas), and surprisingly resourceful for a Muppet, and you might become just a bit more Yoda.

We take the quizzes.  We tell our friends -- tongue firmly in cheek and self-effacing-sarcasm meter cranked to “high” -- that we are Basil.  And then we try – honestly, if imperfectly -- to live up to our own leafy, herbal accolades.

“You have a beautiful soul, and it shines through in the way you treat others.” 

Yes.  Yes, it really does, my friend. 

…Your bouts of self-reflection have made you wiser.  May you live long and prosper.

See?  See?  I AM Spock.  I knew it all along.





*That is, not yet.  Anyone want to hold a Halloween party this year?